Introduction

The relationship between Rhaenyra Targaryen and Alicent Hightower, two influential women in the world of A Song of Ice and Fire, often portrayed as bitter rivals, is a complex narrative replete with political intrigue and personal betrayal. While their animosity intensified over time, their initial relationship may have been less antagonistic than commonly depicted. Understanding the evolution of their relationship provides insight into the motivations and actions of both women during the turbulent period of "the Dance of the Dragons."

Early Relationship and Mutual Fondness

Before their rivalry escalated, Rhaenyra and Alicent shared a cordial relationship. During the early years of King Viserys I's reign, the idea of a stepmother for Rhaenyra did not appear to be a significant concern. The young Princess Rhaenyra seemed relatively accepting of the marriage between her father and Lady Alicent Hightower. This was evidenced by her presence at the royal wedding, where she poured wine for the new queen. The mutual affection extended to personal interactions, with Alicent showing physical affection and feminine warmth by kissing her on both cheeks and even calling her "daughter."

The Rise of Rivalry

However, the relationship between Rhaenyra and Alicent began to sour with the birth of Alicent's sons. Alicent, eager to secure power and having sons who were part Hightower through her marriage, viewed Rhaenyra’s legacy on the throne as a threat. This led to a significant shift in their relationship, marked by betrayal and mistrust. The personal and political environment deteriorated, leading to a deep-seated enmity between the women.

Political and Personal Betrayals

The political maneuverings of both sides contributed to the hatred that developed. Alicent's father, Ser Otto Hightower, supported her in her quest for the throne, while Rhaenyra's uncle, Prince Daemon Targaryen, aligned with her. The succession dispute became personal, with both parties making significant sacrifices and taking extreme measures in their pursuit of the crown. The bitter relationship culminated in the Dance of the Dragons, where the personal conflict between the two queens became intertwined with the deadly war for the Iron Throne.

Keys to the Evolution of Their Relationship

Several key events further exacerbated the hatred between the Targaryen princess and the Hightower queen:

The decision of King Viserys I to name Rhaenyra as his heir, which Alicent perceived as a personal slight. The rivalry between Ser Otto Hightower and Daemon Targaryen, leading to their respective exiles. The symbolic green and black feasts that signified a clear divide in their factions. The political marriages that solidified alliances and created inner-family rivalries. The deaths of both Alicent’s sons and daughter, fueling personal and political grief.

Conclusion

Rhaenyra and Alicent's relationship evolved from mutual fondness to intense hatred, driven by their destinies as twin heirs to the Iron Throne. While they may not have hated each other at the outset, the gradual erosion of their bond was fundamentally rooted in their conflict for power. Their fates and actions during "the Dance of the Dragons" illustrate the complexities of political and personal relationships in a world where power and honor were highly valued.