Which is Better: Gaming Router or WiFi Extender with Ethernet?

Digging through the debate on whether a gaming router or a WiFi extender with an Ethernet cable is the better choice, you might find yourself a bit lost. With so many opinions out there, it's crucial to break down the differences and understand which solution might best suit your needs.

Understanding the Limitations

First and foremost, it's important to note that anything is likely better than a WiFi extender traditionally. WiFi extenders operate at a fraction of Ethernet speed, typically less than 25 percent, even in ideal situations. In my personal experience, they are virtually useless, making Ethernet the preferred choice whenever possible.

The Role of Gaming Routers

Gaming routers are designed to enhance WiFi connections, which can lead to a more stable and faster gaming experience. However, if you are already using an Ethernet cable, the added benefits of a gaming router, such as Quality of Service (QoS) prioritization, are significantly reduced. In many cases, the Ethernet bypasses most of the advantages that these specialized routers offer.

Performance and Reliability

For most gaming purposes, a wired solution is the way to go due to its reliability and speed. Wireless solutions, including gaming routers and WiFi extenders, can introduce latency and packet collisions, which can result in lag during gameplay. For the most reliable and fast gaming experience, consider using an Ethernet cable directly from your gaming rig to your router.

Other Wireless Solutions and Technologies

Other wireless solutions, such as MoCA technology, can also be used to enhance gaming. While WiFi range extenders can improve WiFi coverage, they still require the data to be sent and received twice, making them substantially slower compared to a wired repeater.

Objective Speed Testing

To truly address your internet connection issues, it is crucial to run an independent internet speed testing application. Applications like the FCC speedtest or others from trusted third-party providers will offer you a more accurate and unbiased result. Often, your own internet service provider's speed test can be biased due to their desire to justify their product's performance to you.

Conclusion

If you are looking for a reliable and fast connection for gaming, an Ethernet cable bypasses most of the advantages of a gaming router and WiFi extender. The best practice is to connect your gaming rig directly to your existing router with an Ethernet cable. This setup can provide the best possible performance and eliminate the risk of latency and packet collisions that wireless solutions introduce.

Remember, the key to a great gaming experience lies in the strength and stability of your internet connection. Whether you choose to stick with your current router, use a gaming router, or opt for a wireless range extender or MoCA technology, always prioritize reliability and speed for the best gaming performance.